web metrics
 

Nutrition & Research Reviews

Each month we scan dozens of  research journals looking for the best and most relevent information to share with you.


OCTOBER, 2004

Strength Training Burns Calories After Exercise


Most people look to aerobic exercise to burn calories, but strength training can also burn calories during and after training.

In this study, 14 women performed two different workouts on two separate occasions. In one session, they performed a relatively light strength training session, doing 2 sets of 15 reps per exercise. In a second session, they lifted more intensely, performing 2 sets of 8 reps per exercise.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

 

The women burned more calories for hours after the harder, more intense workout.


Alwyn Cosgrove calls this the “Afterburn”, and we call it one of the reasons that the workouts in ShapeShift are so effective. There’s a lot more to fat loss than the number of calories that you burn on the treadmill.

 

Thornton, M., et al. Effects of resistance exercise bouts of different intensities but equal work on EPOC. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 34: 715-722, 2002.

 


 

 

The Benefits of Interval Training


Trainers and coaches are learning that no matter what the goal, clients and athletes have to include some form of interval training in their program. Interval training is extremely effective for improving fitness and increasing fat loss.

In this classic study, 32 women went through an 8-week program and trained either 2 or 4 days per week. Some women trained with short intervals (under 200 meters) and others with longer intervals (up to 1000 meters).

Interval training helped subjects increase their VO2max by 13%, but no interval training method was found to be better than the other for improving fitness. That means that training 4 days per week with longer intervals was no more effective than training for 2 days with shorter intervals. Regardless, a 13% increase in VO2max is huge. Team sport athletes and endurance athletes would love to have those kinds of gains.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

 

To improve fitness, athletes should include at least 2 days of
intervals per week. Short intervals (~200 meters) appear to be just as good as longer intervals (up to 1200 meters). The key to success with interval training is intensity – something you just can’t maintain during 30 minute slow cardio sessions.

Don’t forget to always warm-up properly for intense training.

      Lesmes, G., et al. Metabolic responses of females to high intensity interval training of different frequencies. Med. Sci. Sports. 10: 229-232, 1978.


 


Eat Healthy & Lose Fat


No matter what “today’s low-carbohydrate diets” are telling you, fruits and vegetables must be included in your diet if you want to be as healthy as possible. Fortunately, eating an increased amount of fruits and vegetables is also a factor in fat loss. Don’t let any book talk you out of eating fruits and vegetables.

In this review study, researchers looked at the nutrition habits of over 70,000 women. In women with the largest fruit and vegetable intake, there was a lower risk of gaining fat.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

  

The researchers concluded that, “increasing intake of fruits and vegetables may reduce long-term risk of obesity and weight gain among middle-aged women”. This information might not be as sexy as the latest diet, but it helps, its realistic and it’s healthy.

 

He, K., et al. Changes in intake of fruits and vegetables in relation to risk of obesity and weight gain among middle-aged women. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. Oct, 2004.



 

 

Predicting Success in a Fat Loss Program

Why can some women succeed at fat loss on their first try while other women seem to have the worst luck every time they start a new fat loss program? Every woman needs to find their best sources of support and motivation.

In this study, 158 women tried to lose fat by entering into a lifestyle program. The women completed behavioral and psychosocial tests, as well as providing diet and exercise habits. Women were considered a success if they lost 5% of their body weight or 10% of their fat weight. (At grrlAthlete.com we believe that much great results can be obtained by following a healthy eating program and an intense exercise program like ShapeShift.)

Some women dropped out, and this was associated with factors such as low-carbohydrate intake, Fitness-Exercise-Nutrition weight loss attempts, and a poorer quality of life. Of the successful women, they were associated with fewer Fitness-Exercise-Nutrition attempts at dieting and more moderate expectations.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

 

There are a lot of factors that impact the success of a weight loss program. Therefore, it is important for women to properly prepare themselves prior to committing to a fat loss program. In our Simple Fat Loss manual that we will be releasing shortly, we’ll include a multi-stage preparation plan to get you on the fast track for fat loss. In it we’ll teach you the three most important factors for a successful fat loss program.

 

Teixeira, P., et al. Pretreatment predictors of attrition and successful weight management in women. Int. J. Obes. 28: 1124-1133, 2004.


 


Calorie Intake & Meal Size


If you’ve been out to eat recently, you’re well aware of the massive portion sizes that are dominating the American restaurant scene. Research has shown that people eat more when larger portion sizes are served. In addition, many foods at restaurants are “energy dense” (such as French fries), meaning that they contain a lot of calories per serving, and many more calories per serving than less energy dense foods such as broccoli.

In this study, 39 women were fed breakfast, lunch and dinner once per week for 6 weeks. Each time, the lunch serving was different and it varied in both energy density and portion size. They ended up eating 6 different lunches over the 6 weeks.

The researchers found that the women ate 56% more food (223 Calories in this study) when they were served the largest portion size of food that also had the greatest energy density. That means a light lunch could turn into half your day’s food intake, depending on how wisely you order. And what’s even worse is that these women didn’t feel fuller or make up for it at dinner by eating less food. Therefore, energy dense foods eaten in large proportions are a recipe for fat gain.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

 

When you are planning your meals at home and ordering at restaurants, make sure to choose small portions and foods that don’t contain a lot of calories per serving. Avoid large portion sizes and foods that are energy dense. Read food labels and ask your server for more information on your order.


Kral, T., et al. Combined effects of energy density and portion size on energy intake in women. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 79: 962-968, 2004.




South Beach Diet Research Review



The South Beach Diet is one of the most popular diet programs of all time. It might even be more popular than the Atkins diet, and to be quite honest with you, it has a lot more positives than the original Atkins phase.

In this study (conducted in part by the physician that wrote the book), a South Beach-type diet was compared against the recommended diet from the US National Cholesterol Education Program [NCEP]. The NCEP diet removes saturated fat from the diet and replaces it with carbohydrates while the South Beach-type diet replaced saturated fat with protein and mono-unsaturated fats.

Sixty overweight patients were put on one of the diet (both men and women) for 12 weeks. The subjects on the South Beach-type diet lost more weight (13.6 pounds) than the NCEP diet (7.5 pounds). Only the South Beach-type diet made significant improvements in cholesterol levels.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

 

Score one for the South Beach-type diet. By replacing saturated fats with protein and mono-unsaturated fats, the South Beach-type diet was able to lose more weight and make big cholesterol improvements in 12-weeks. It would have been nice for this study to go on longer. Hopefully we will get more information and research on long, long term results.


Aude, Y., et al. The National Cholesterol Education Program Diet vs a Diet Lower in Carbohydrates and Higher in Protein and Monounsaturated Fat. A Randomized Trial. Arch. Intern. Med. 164: 2141-2146, 2004.  


 SEPTEMBER, 2004

 

Work out and Play in the Same Day

  • 18 female NCAA Division 1 Basketball players performed either a whole body weight training workout or rested.
  • The weight training workout was a whole body workout consisting of 3 to 4 sets of 7 exercises.
  • 6 hours later the subjects performed tests to predict game performance; including vertical jump (2 legs), mean power output for 30 seconds, and shooting accuracy over 60 seconds.
  • The authors found no difference in vertical jump, anaerobic power or shooting accuracy between the days when the subjects worked out, or did not work out prior to testing.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU:

  • The evidence from this studies adds proof to the idea that with a properly planned strength training program, same day game play should not be effected, even with as little as 6 hours between your work-out and actual game play.

 

     Vertical jump, anaerobic power, and shooting accuracy are not altered 6 hours after strength training in collegiate women basketball players. Woolstenhulme, M.T., Bailey, B.K. and Allsen, P.E. J Strength Cond Res. 18(3):422-425. 2004.


 AUGUST, 2004

 

Interval Training Leads to Greater Fat Loss
  • Young men and women completed a 20-week endurance-training (ET) program or a 15-week high-intensity interval-training (HIIT) program.
  • Subjects burned more calories per session when performing endurance exercise, but the HIIT program resulted in greater fat loss.
  • In conclusion, the researchers found that more vigorous exercise causes greater fat loss.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Interval training is superior for fat loss (just ask some of our fitness models on the site!).
  • Don't get hung up on how many calories you burn in a training session.

Tremblay, A., et al. Impact of exercise intensity on body fatness and skeletal muscle metabolism. Metabolism 43: 814-818, 1994.


Weight Training & Calorie Burning
  • Women who were currently training with weights were recruited for this study. Each woman performed two different workouts.
  • After each session, energy expenditure (calorie burning) was measured for 24 hours.
  • In session 1, they performed 2 sets of 15 repetitions for 9 exercises.
  • In session 2, they performed 2 sets of 8 repetitions for the same 9 exercises.
  • The results showed that the high intensity resistance training workout (2 sets of 8 repetitions) resulted in greater total daily energy expenditure.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • A heavy weight training session results in more calories burned over the next 24 hours than a light weight training session.
  • Heavy resistance training is under-rated by those seeking to lose body fat but it may be the best type of exercise.
  • Resistance training promotes both energy expenditure and muscle!

Thornton, K., et al. A comparison of two different resistance-training intensities on exercise energy expenditure and excess post-exercise oxygen consumption. American College of Sports Medicine, 2001.


Your Sport & Healthy Bones
  • Young female runners have a greater bone mineral density (BMD) than swimmers, cyclists, or sedentary young women.
  • Higher BMD was seen only in specific sites that were stressed by training.
  • Running increased BMD in the legs and lumbar spine but not the arms.
  • In this study, all the athletes were menstruating normally.
  • Research has shown that athletes with menstrual dysfunction have a decreased BMD.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Weight bearing exercise and strength training are recommended for adolescent females to help achieve peak bone mass.
  • It is very important to eat properly and exercise within your limits.

Duncan, C., et al. Bone mineral density in adolescent female athletes: relationship to exercise type and muscle strength. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc. 34: 286-294, 2002.


Healthy Bones! Calcium, Exercise & Bone Mass
  • Calcium intake at age 11-14 is more predictive of bone mass for females aged 21-24 then Calcium intake at any other time.
  • Physical inactivity in late adolescence (15-20 years) was only age interval that showed negative relationship with bone mass.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • The researchers suggested that it is very important that pre-teen girls consume a diet high in calcium in order to develop strong bones.
  • When social pressures cause girls to quit sports, they tend to lose bone mass - so keep them in the game!

Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 75: 356s, 2002.


Exercise & Body Image
  • The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of different training programs on body image in young women.
  • One group performed aerobic training only and the other group performed aerobic training plus strength training and a third group performed no training.
  • Body image was assessed with a Body Self-Image Questionnaire.
  • Results indicated that the combined aerobics plus strength-training group had greater improvements in strength and fitness than the other 2 groups.
  • The combined training group also had a better decrease in body fat.
  • Most importantly, the combined training group had significantly more positive body image profiles than the group that did not exercise.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Females should perform both aerobic training and resistance training for health and body image reasons.

Henry, R., and T. Michael. The effect of aerobic and aerobic/strength training on body image in females. American College of Sports Medicine, 2001.


JULY, 2004
Weight Training Improves Body Image in Women
  • 49 women participated in a strength-training program for 12 weeks.
  • At the completion of the study most subjects reported feeling healthier and more fit and had a better attitude about their physical selves.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • A regular weight-training program can improve your quality of life and self esteem.

Ahmed, C., et al. J. Str. Cond. Res. 16: 645-648, 2002.


Weights Increases Muscle & Strength, and Decreases Body Fat
  • 20 females participated in a weight-training program to determine the effects of training on resting metabolic rate, fat-free mass, strength, and dietary intake.
  • 10 subjects trained for 12-weeks (2 total-body workouts/week; 6 exercises x 3 sets x 10 reps) program and ten subjects were controls.
  • The results indicated a low-volume of moderate-intensity resistance training increased strength and decreased body fat without dieting.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU

  • All women should incorporate resistance training in their fitness regimens, especially young women seeking improvements in their body composition.
  • Furthermore, the total time commitment for an improvement in body composition was only 2 hours per week, making weight training a time efficient training method.

Cullinen, K. and M. Caldwell. J. American Dietetic Association 98: 414-418, 1998.


Pre-Season Training Helps Prevent Injury in Female Soccer Players

  • 300 female soccer players (ages 14 to 18 years) were studied over a 1-year period.
  • 42 out of the 300 players participated in a 7-week training program before the season.
  • Injuries were recorded during the season. All injuries occurred in the lower extremities, with 61% occurring at the knee and ankle.
  • The trained group experienced a significantly lower incidence of injury than the untrained group.
  • Although not statistically significant, the trained group also had a lower percentage (2.4%) of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries compared with the untrained group (3.1%).
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Pre-season training is associated with injury prevention in female adolescent soccer players.
  • Locate a certified strength and conditioning specialist (CSCS) in your area for a pre-season training program.
  • Read Issue #4 on www.grrlAthlete.com to learn more about soccer conditioning.

Heidt, R., et al. Avoidance of soccer injuries with preseason conditioning. Am. J. Sports Med. 28: 659-662, 2000.


Calcium & Bone Density
  • Bone mineral content was 6% lower in women who consumed less than 1 serving of milk per week than in those who consumed more than 1 serving per day during childhood.
  • Low milk intake in childhood was associated with a 2-fold greater risk of fracture.
  • Low milk intake during adolescence was associated with a 3% reduction in hip bone mineral content and bone mineral density.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Females that don't drink a lot of milk (or consume a lot of dairy products) during childhood and adolescence have less bone mass and a greater risk of fracture when they are adults.

Kalkwarf, H., et al. Milk intake during childhood and adolescence, adult bone density, and osteoporotic fractures in US women. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 77: 257-265, 2003.


Vitamin K & Bone Density
  • This study established a positive association between consumption of dietary vitamin K and bone mineral density in young and older women.
  • Women that had a low intake of vitamin K had lower bone mineral density, which is associated with increases in the risk of a hip fracture.
  • Women who had the highest vitamin K intake had the highest bone mineral density values.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • In addition to calcium, women should emphasize consuming sources of Vitamin K in their diet.

Booth, S., et al. Vitamin K intake and bone mineral density in women and men. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 77: 512-516, 2003.


JUNE, 2004
Runners & Bone Mineral Density
  • Fifty-two female endurance runners (1500 m to marathon) were tested.
  • Runners of longer distances had lower bone mineral density (BMD) in the lumbar spine and the femoral neck (the bone of the thigh).
  • Body mass was positively associated with BMD meaning that bigger girls had healthier bones.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU

·          Females that run very long distances and have a low body mass have a greater risk of low bone mineral density.

·          Either of these risk factors should be discussed with a physician.

 

Burrows, M., et al. Physiological factors associated with low bone mineral density in female endurance runners.   Br. J. Sports Med. 37: 67-71, 2003.


Post-workout Nutrition Improves Subsequent Performance
  • 10 healthy young female endurance athletes performed 4 60-min cycling workouts on 4 days (day 1, 3, 4, and 6).
  • On day 7, participants performed a ride to exhaustion.
  • Subjects repeated this protocol under two conditions
  • CON = Subjects consumed a placebo after each workout.
  • POST = Subjects consumed a carbohydrate beverage after each workout.
  • Subjects were able to cycle longer on the day 7 "exhaustion ride" when they had consumed post-workout supplements after the 4 Fitness-Exercise-Nutrition workouts.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Consuming a carbohydrate beverage after endurance training workouts will improve performance in upcoming races and long training sessions.

Roy, B., et al. The influence of post-exercise macronutrient intake on energy balance and protein metabolism in active females participating in endurance training. Int. J. Sport Nutr. Exerc. Metab. 12: 172-188, 2002.


Dietary intake of female U.S. soccer players

·          The Under-21 (U-21) United States women's national soccer team reported consuming 2015 kcal per day.

·          The contribution of protein, fat and carbohydrate to total energy intake were 15%, 30% and 55%, respectively.

·          The researchers found that the athlete's dietary intakes of vitamins D and E were less than two-thirds of the recommendations.

·          In general, the responses to the nutrition attitude questions suggest that these athletes may benefit from appropriate education regarding the role of nutrients in health and performance.

WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU

·          The authors suggested that "young female soccer players should be encouraged to eat small, high carbohydrate nutrient dense meals, frequently throughout the day, and they should be provided with appropriate nutrition counseling."

·          If you are an elite female athlete, you should meet with a Registered Dietician to appropriately plan your daily food intake.

 

Mullinixa, M., et al. Nutrition Research 23: 585-593, 2003.


MAY, 2004
Higher Dietary Protein to Preserve Muscle While Dieting
  • In a study conducted by the University of Adelaide in Australia, fifty-seven overweight volunteers were fed one of two weight loss diets:
  • Group 1 followed a high-protein diet (27% of energy as protein, 44% as carbohydrate and 29% as fat).
  • Group 2 followed a "standard diet" (16% of energy as protein, 57% as carbohydrate, and 27% as fat).
  • Both diets were low calorie (1400-1500 kcals) and were followed for 12 weeks.
  • After 12 weeks, both groups returned to energy balance (~1950 kcals) for 4 weeks.
  • After 12 weeks:
  • Weight loss (17.4 lbs) and total fat loss (15.2) were not different between groups.
  • However, the women in the high protein diet group had a better preservation of lean mass than the standard diet.
  • There were no changes in markers of bone turnover, calcium excretion or systolic blood pressure.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Replacing carbohydrates with meat, poultry, fish and dairy foods in a low calorie diet has been shown to preserve lean mass in overweight women with no effect on bone turnover or calcium excretion.
  • If you are dieting, you should consult with a Registered Dietician to design an appropriate nutrition plan.

Farnsworth, E, et al. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 78: 31-39, 2003.


APRIL, 2004
The Incidence of Injuries in Elite Junior Figure Skaters
  • 236 elite female figure skaters were questioned to determine the frequency of injuries and overuse syndromes.
  • 25% of the female skaters reported sustaining acute injuries.
  • 43% of the female skaters reported overuse syndromes.
  • Low back pain was reported by 19 of the 236 female skaters.
  • The most frequent acute injury was ankle sprain.
  • In singles female skaters, the most frequent overuse injury was stress fracture (19.8%), followed by jumper's knee (14.9%).
  • More than 50% of injuries in young singles figure skaters involved overuse syndromes.
  • Pairs skaters and ice dance skaters had a higher risk of acute injury than overuse syndrome because of falls from lifts and throw jumps.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • The authors suggest that strength and conditioning programs designed to improve postural alignment, flexibility, and strength, especially during a young female skater's time of development, should be instituted to prevent and reduce overuse syndromes.

The American Journal of Sports Medicine 31:511-517, 2003.


Female Anterior Cruciate Ligament (ACL) Injury & "Relaxin" Receptors
  • Non-contact ACL injuries occur two to eight times more often in women than in men.
  • Changes in ligament laxity and strength have been associated with female hormones such as relaxin.
  • ACL ligaments from five women and five men were compared.
  • The ACL sections from the females women (but not from the males) showed binding to relaxin.
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • The hormone "relaxin" appears to bind to specific relaxin receptors in the female anterior cruciate ligament. This could be one of the many factors contributing to the greater risk of ACL injury in females.
  • Female athletes should seek out a Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialist for an appropriate training program to help otherwise minimize the risk of ACL injury.

The American Journal of Sports Medicine 31:577-584, 2003.


 

A Survey of the Scientific Data and Training Methods Utilized by Collegiate Strength and Conditioning
  • A recent survey of 137 NCAA division I strength and conditioning coaches examined what techniques these coaches used to train their athletes and where they got their programs and philosophy from.
  • 47% of the respondents ranked their peers and other strength coaches as their number 1 resource for information.
  • Almost half of the respondents reported that the strength programs they used as athletes influenced the programs they teach their teams today.
  • Almost all strength coaches that responded held a masters degree in a human performance field and were Certified Strength and Conditioning Specialists (CSCS) accredited by the National Strength and Condition Association (NSCA).
WHAT THIS MEANS TO YOU
  • Even NCAA division I coaches use other people and coaches as a source of information about training. No one person has all the answers.
  • The more resourceful you are the better chance you have of coming up with effective training strategies that will work for you.

Durell, D., et al. The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 17: 368-373, 2003